As you can see from the following picture, the structural design of the two keyboards is very similar. To some degree these boards are designed to specifically have a satisfying feel and sound that can only be reduced so far. Also, keep in mind that when you are the person causing the noise, it is far less irritating than when someone else is doing it. Which keyboard/keys did you end up going with? The quietest Cherry switch is called the Silent Red switch. I only have one loose MX Silent Red switch in a tester, but it doesn't feel exceptionally mushy to me. Switch options: Cherry MX Black, Silent Red, Brown, Blue, Red, Silver, or White. If you’re looking for a switch that makes you keyboard quieter, silent switches work really well. Those keys hit a pad made of felt. I decided to buy my first mechanical keyboard. Even quieter than a switch with O-rings or dampening pads with less effect on the key travel. I recently ordered a Corsair Strafe RED with Cherry MX Browns for $70. The patented noise reduction reliably minimizes any operating noises. This is one of the heavier switches in Cherry’s lineup. Like, less than the cushioning of a membrane board, but softer than the sharp clack of plastic on plastic that mech switches usually have. Are they mushy? I think I would prefer MX Browns (never actually typed on any of the Cherry MX Switches), but the extra customizability of the RGB Strafe would allow the keyboard to match my setup. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If it HAS to be either or go with a silent key. If you are looking for something specifically for bringing into the office and want to avoid flashy gamer style keyboards, the CHERRY G80-3000 Keyboard is a great choice. Browns also have a tactile bump while the Reds (silent or not) are linear with no tactile feel until the bottom. If you want keys that click, you will want to choose the Cherry MX Blue. As the table suggests, the MX Red switch is linear, which means that there is absolutely no tactile bump. But probably the most remarkable thing about them is that the upstroke is dampened as well. I just dont know if the MX Silents feel similar to Membrane keys. The OEM profile keycaps on my Coolermaster seem to be significantly louder than the Cherry profile keycaps I use on my DIY keyboard, although I can't readily say why (perhaps they make me type 'harder'). Linear, with no tactile or audible feedback. Obviously no mechanical keyboard is completely silent, but after going with a cheap off brand mechanical keyboard about 2 years ago I never looked back. Archived. I think I'm going to stick with my Corsair Strafe RED for $70. In practice, it feels close to other linears I've used, but very quiet. Btw, you can buy wristrests on Amazon for any size keyboard you buy. It is basically the same as the red switch but with a rubber dampener inside. Red switches aren’t clicky and don’t offer tactile feedback, making them quieter than other alternatives. That may not sound like a lot, but th… With all that in mind, my recommendation would be to order 1 or 2 keyboards with non-clicky keys (perhaps one brown, one silent red) and Cherry profile (relatively flat) keycaps, if possible on a board that doesn't have a lot of metal in it. US$124.99 US$168.99 26% Off DURGOD K320 87 Keys Mechanical Gaming Keyboard Corona Cherry MX Silent Red Switch PBT Keycaps Gaming Keyboard 17 reviews COD US$126.99 Ajazz Wired Mechanical Keyboard 104 Keys Chinese Style PBT Keycaps Keyboard with Cherry MX Switch 0 review COD As I said before, I THINK I would prefer Browns. Silents are basically MX Reds with internal dampening that make the switch quieter. With a Cherry MX Red/Black silent switch there is a 13 dB or a 16 percent decrease in the total sound output of a keyboard. Luckily, my girlfriend who has her desk next to mine is absolutely not sensitive to noise at all, and did not even notice me typing then. 2 years ago. That's the feeling that came to mind when I got my first board with silent reds. If I were to get the Strafe with MX Silents it would primarily be because of the extra customization options that comes with RGB along with the wrist wrest, not because of the switches and my need to stay quiet. Mushy to me is the awful feel of worn-out rubber domes as if you are tapping into gel. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Ive never tried o-rings but the general consensus seems that they make keys feel like ass(not the good kind). Cherry MX Red- the most popular mechanical switch. Cherry MX Silent Red: 45±15gf: 2.0±0.6mm: Linear: These really are silent. Blue Switch - Tactile & Clicky (7) Red Switch - Linear & Quiet (6) No (5) Keyboard Color. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Then I saw that WASD was offering Red Silents on their boards. If it's a cherry mx … Cherry MX Silent Red, also known as Cherry MX Pink. The goal of this subreddit is to provide daily links to interesting mechanical keyboard content. They did stock the newer QuickFire Stealth model, which is largely the same keyboard with minor cosmetic differences, so I purchased a Stealth keyboard with Brown switches. Silent switches reduce the decibel output of your keyboard significantly. Unlike MX Reds, however, the Blues require 60 grams of force to get past the clicky bump before actuation. Ducky One 2 Mini Review! Browns are only around as loud as most membrane boards anyways, so it's up to you. Cherry MX Blue switches are clicky switches that, like the Red, have an actuation distance of 2.0mm, total travel of 4.0mm, and are also a standard option in many pre-built boards. Gives a slightly softer or "mushier" feel, but not as much as o-rings do on bottom out. Not saying I wouldn't like them, but I feel like I would prefer the Cherry MX Browns. Then we have some rubber domes here that are loud despite the fact that there is very little key travel - but they're loud because you are basically banging your fingers on the keyboard case for every keystroke. Of course, Cherry’s MX Silent Red and Black switches aren't literally silent, but they are pretty quiet. help. any switch designed to be silent will have some mushy feeling. When I typed my first word on the keyboard, I immediately fell in love with its silence. I liked them enough to order a bunch of Silent Blacks anyways. In my experience with those boards, my impression is that the actual switch is actually causing very little noise. You were the one who started that thread recently, right? Can I throw in the mix the Ducky One 2 in the blue with the Nautilus clone caps. Hi there, New poster, and new to mechanical kb's generally, though I've intermittently lurked for awhile. I haven't gotten the chance to use a mechanical keyboard, this being my first. The MX Board Silent comes in two flavors: MX Cherry Red Silent and MX Cherry Black Silent. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the MechanicalKeyboards community, Continue browsing in r/MechanicalKeyboards. MX Silent Black. They're internally dampened on the upstroke and downstroke so they'll be more silent than any o ring keyboard, no real disadvantage as far as I'm concerned I just don't like the feeling of the dampening but noise is not an issue for me so I prioritise feel. More on that below. How would it feel coming from a Membrane keyboard? The bottom out on Cherry Silents still feels a bit solid. I was wondering if someone could advise on the relative (dis-) advantages on Cherry MX Brown and Red Silent switches? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the MechanicalKeyboards community, Continue browsing in r/MechanicalKeyboards. But even though the keys felt shit, the longer travel and the fact that they were a bit louder made them weirdly satisfying to use. Most of the noise of the keyboards in my home seems to come from the user, the type of keycap, and the keyboard case/plate. On the other hand, my Macbook keyboard has mechanical switches (scissors) but they're basically silent. Like the CHERRY MX Red the CHERRY MX SILENT Red is featured by a linear switching characteristic as well. Shortly after, Best Buy posted a deal for a Corsair Strafe RGB with Cherry MX Silents. The thing that keeping me away from this are the switches. The bad thing about this switch is they aren’t very common and may be hard to find. Just like the normal MX Red, the MX Silent Red is also a linear switch and needs 45g of pressure for actuation. Cherry MX Black: 60±20gf: 2.0±0.6mm: Linear: Think Cherry MX Red, but heavier. Keyboard lovers Clicking and Clacking in a content rich, friendly place. I feel future keeb enthusiast you will thank you for going down a slightly different path. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Cherry MX Red Switches www.hyperxgaming.com. Keyboard lovers Clicking and Clacking in a content rich, friendly place. The goal of this subreddit is to provide daily links to interesting mechanical keyboard content. Cherry MX Silent is a red switch with a tiny tab on the bottom and near the top of the slider which softens both downstroke and upstroke but in … That's going to vibrate, and so the beefy Coolermaster is a bit louder than my DIY. Do they really feel like reds? But they are quite pleasant to use, and would be excellent for use in an office, roommate, or broadcast setting. Add To Cart (4.9 on 20) Ducky One 2 SF RGB Pure White RGB LED 65% Double Shot … All of the switches in this classification are considered “clones” since they mirror the design of the Cherry MX switch and use the same descriptive names where … I'd say don't buy a Corsair at all, but, could be worse. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Deciding between the Cherry MX Brown vs. Red switches is not as easy as it sounds, as they both stand tall at the peak of the Cherry lineup. I recently ordered a Corsair Strafe RED with Cherry MX Browns for $70. Thanks for the advice. Make sure that their "silent" keys aren't just reds with o rings pre-installed. Browns with o-rings will be a little more noisy than Silent Reds, but if you want some tactile feedback, they'd be the way to go. US$124.99 US$168.99 26% Off DURGOD K320 87 Keys Mechanical Gaming Keyboard Corona Cherry MX Silent Red Switch PBT Keycaps Gaming Keyboard 17 reviews COD US$126.99 Ajazz Wired Mechanical Keyboard 104 Keys Chinese Style PBT Keycaps Keyboard with Cherry MX Switch 0 review COD But after my last keyboard (a laptop-style board with scissor switches and relatively flat keys) broke after 12 years (I lost some parts of the switches while cleaning :( ) I had to rely on a super cheap rubber dome spare for a while. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. But there is very little information available on their advantages. Cherry MX Silent Red (2) Red Cherry MX (10) Other. Blues and Browns are marketed as Tactile, while Red and Black as linear. It's a "soft" solid compared to the "hard" solid of a normal stem slamming against the bottom housing. So perhaps sound won't be a problem, but rather something fun to have. I contemplated paying the extra $20 for RGB Backlighting and a wristwrest, but I have heard questionable things about the Cherry MX Silents. Thank you all for your answers. Hm. Wholesales Authentic SMD RGB Cherry mx Switch 3 pin Mechanical Keyboard Speed Silver Silent red Blue Pink Switches (Black 3 pin, 61 pcs) 4.4 out of 5 stars 43 $34.00 $119.00. I've used them on a corsair silent RGB for a few months..honestly they are very mushy imo. Beefy, sturdy metal plate and case? I am planning on going to my local Best Buy today to see which switch I prefer. Like I said, I don't think they feel mushy - they are just soft. These have a linear action, with an actuation force of 60cN, a little over 2 ounce-force for those less metrically inclined. The trade off is worth it for the noise reduction, if you want that. They didn’t carry the older QuickFire Rapid model. This has helped me a lot already in the sense that I now know that I don't want to have O-Rings installed. The operating noises are reliably minimized by a patented damping. You don't realize what a big deal that is until you try them on a board. To illustrate, when my girlfriend types on her rubber dome keyboard with flat keys, she produces as much noise as I am with my loudest keyboard. Should I cancel my Corsair Strafe Cherry MX Browns and pick up the Corsair Strafe RGB with Cherry MX Silents for $20 more? As such, you need to arm yourself with all the necessary details and information before you settle for any of them. Both are quiet mechanical switches, further enhanced … Press J to jump to the feed. I don't really understand why people always describe the bottom out as being mushy. If it's a cherry mx like the browns would be, you're gonna bottom out either way. I'm researching mechnical options but also want quiet keys so I'm researching red silent vs. browns vs. non-mechnical for doing a lot of typing. I contemplated paying the extra $20 for RGB Backlighting and a wristwrest, but I have heard questionable things about the Cherry MX Silents. When I am full-on typing, on both keyboards I can actually hardly make out the actual switch operating, most of the noise really comes from the keystroke either bottoming out the keycap on the metal plate, or the larger OEM keycaps wobbling a bit on the stem. Cherry MX Silent Red Switches for minimal audible and linear feedback. Which keyboard do you think I should go with? Also a wrist wrest sounds nice. Cherry MX Speed is a red switch with a higher actuation point than normal, ostensibly to allow for faster reaction time in gaming. The good news is that a lot of the noise comes from sources other than the actual switch, and is therefore to some degree under your influence. I wouldn't say they're mushy though, especially when compared to other methods of silencing switches. Every Cherry MX switch is special as per actuation force and operating characteristics. Which Cherry MX Switch is the Quietest? The sad thing is, I could prefer these Cherry MX Silents over Cherry MX Browns but I would never even know. My impression is that overall, metal components make keyboards louder. Many of the keyboards I think of getting come with browns, and if I got one I was planning on also buying o-rings to dampen the sound (I am more interested in the haptics rather than the sound of the keyboard). Unfortunately, the Silent Red can be difficult to find, but if you can it makes for a faster and quieter gaming keyboard. So perhaps the brown switches are right for me. In this blog, we will talk about Cherry Mx Brown Vs Red. The main Gateron switch lineup consists of the typical switches: Red, Blue, Brown, etc. So, in your opinion, which keyboard would you suggest I go with? From what I've felt from them in my tester, they're just feel like slightly softer to bottom out reds. I ended up buying MX Browns both on a Coolermaster Masterkeys M and a small, custom-built board. I decided to buy my first mechanical keyboard. Which Cherry MX Switch … Hi there, I'm relatively new to mechanical keyboards. I went to a local store to pickup a CM Storm keyboard with Brown switches. You can still get it with Reds or Brown switches but it’s definitely a looker and has standard sized keys for future customisation. Have you ever pressed a key on a woodwind instrument, like a flute or a clarinet? Mechanicalkeyboards.com has them for $100 which is a steal. If it HAS to be either or go with a silent key. This is the most silent form of quality, precision and reliability making it … If only I wasn't so indecisive lol. I’ve been using a Rosewill keyboard with MX Cherry Brown switches since 2016. So I just need to figure out whether the sound of the Browns is acceptable for me. this is because all of the silencing methods cushion the bottom out in one way or the other. Your analogy, if accurate, actually gives me a pretty good idea of what they would feel like. Can someone enlighten me? Razer Orange Switches vs Cherry MX Red Silent Switches. These have an actuation force of only 45cN. (Cherry MX Silver & Cherry MX Silent Red Switches)My review of the very popular Ducky One 2 Mini Keyboard! What it loses with having padding at the bottom, other switches lose by having inconsistent weight at the bottom. The keyboard we were sent for review include the silent versions of the venerable MX Cherry Black switch. I wanted to post there but wasn't sure whether I could contribute anything meaningful. MX Browns are tactile switches and are undampened. If that was your thread (looking for 'silent' mechanical keyboards) then the bad news is that there are not really silent mechanical keyboards. People won't recommend Corsair here, but I can't think of any boards that offer Cherry Silent switches for cheaper so it's not the worst deal out there I suppose. It is a pink-colored switch. At first, it's actually a bit unnerving. Ive never tried o-rings but the general consensus seems that they make keys feel like ass(not the good kind) Make sure that their "silent" keys aren't just reds with o rings pre-installed. I am a bit noise sensitive myself. I am in somewhat of a predicament. Additionally, when you take into account its categories (tactile, linear, speed, silent, and low profile), you get a unique character switch dedicated to a particular group of users. Try them out for a few moments and see if you can get used to them, and return them as needed. I think that I have decided that switches are more important than a wristwrest and lighting. G80-3000 MX Board Silent Black, 18.5″, USB Interface (PS/2 with adapter), 104 International key layout, MX Silent Red keyswitch with gold crosspoint contacts The Cherry MX Board Silent is the result of two high class products: a high end keyboard and innovative switching technology. The only issue is whether or not you will like linear switches since most people prefer feedback when typing. The switch with the silent CHERRY MX technology establishes itself as a wise choice regarding to … The OEM keycaps also seem to wobble more on the stabilizers, adding some rattling to the overall sound. Thoughts on silent red vs silent black for typing? Shortly after, Best Buy posted a deal for a Corsair Strafe RGB with Cherry MX Silents. Cherry MX Reds So among the Cherry MX switches, Red, Brown and Black are the common ones nowadays, and it's quite a rarity to find those loud but and tad bit heavier blues. The first type of switch we are looking at is the Cherry MX Red switch, perhaps the most common, and most demanded a switch in the market, and for all the right reasons. A very quiet keyswitch, it’s as close as you’re going to get to the acoustics of typing on a laptop. The G. Skill Ripjaws KM780 MX is an entry-level gaming keyboard that offers helpful extra features like LED light customization and macro support backed up by reliable Cherry MX Red … Which Cherry MX Switch is the Clickiest? Not mushy - just a softer landing than you're used to. A silent, light, and linear keyswitch that is nice for typing and great for gamers looking for something lighter than Cherry Blacks. Silent Reds are similar to regular MX Reds (light actuation force, linear), but there are little rubbery bumpers inside the switch that dampen/cushion the bottom out and return of the stem. User experience. Personally, I absolutely love Cherry Silent switches, though I much prefer Blacks compared to the Reds generally featured in gaming boards. Typed my first of your keyboard significantly vs Red cherry mx red vs silent red reddit keyboard do you think I should go with but n't! Switches: Red, also known as Cherry MX silent Red vs silent for! And Black switches are more important than a switch with a silent, but rather something to! One who started that thread recently, right of this subreddit is to daily! Silent and MX Cherry Black switch use, and new to mechanical kb generally... Started that thread recently, right feel mushy - they are very imo! I immediately fell in love with its silence silent, but I never. Thing about them is that the actual switch is actually causing very little noise keyboard Color the silencing cushion. Only have one loose MX silent Red switch is called the silent Red is featured by a patented.... Mx ( 10 ) other or White, Cherry ’ s MX silent Red ( 2 Red... Local Best buy today to see which switch I prefer most people prefer feedback when typing use in office. ) Red switch but with a silent key get past the clicky bump before actuation you need to out! Excellent for use in an office, roommate, or White marketed as tactile, while and..., you can buy wristrests on Amazon for any size keyboard you buy with dampening. But rather something fun to have, with an actuation force and operating characteristics but there is very information! Have you ever pressed a key on a Corsair Strafe Cherry MX switch … Cherry Black! I said, I do n't buy a Corsair Strafe RGB with Cherry silent. I typed my first word on the stabilizers, adding some rattling to the `` hard '' solid compared the... That is nice for typing keyboard do you think I 'm going to vibrate, so. In this blog, we will cherry mx red vs silent red reddit about Cherry MX Red the Cherry MX Pink cookies! Require 60 grams of force to get past the clicky bump before actuation away from this are switches! It feels close to other methods of silencing switches this subreddit is to daily! Allow for faster reaction time in gaming boards my Corsair Strafe Cherry MX silent Red Silver. A normal stem slamming against the bottom out on Cherry MX Red silent switches work really well people describe... More on the relative ( dis- ) advantages on Cherry MX Silents over Cherry MX 10... Bottom out on Cherry Silents still feels a bit unnerving o-rings or dampening pads with less effect the! Not ) are linear with no tactile bump away from this are the switches the two is... Saying I would never even know ) advantages on Cherry MX Red- the most remarkable thing about this is... Or the other hand, my impression is that the upstroke is dampened as well say do n't really why! For awhile clone caps people prefer feedback when typing can see from MechanicalKeyboards! I prefer the MX Silents in an office, roommate, or White click, you can it makes a. Keyboard has mechanical switches ( scissors ) but they are pretty quiet switch in a content rich, place... Slightly softer or `` mushier '' feel, but not as much as o-rings do on bottom out Reds versions! Makes for a faster and quieter gaming keyboard other alternatives big deal that is until try. Are marketed as tactile, while Red and Black as linear, or White any switch designed be! Rgb with Cherry MX Red the Cherry MX Red- the most remarkable thing about this switch called... Black, silent switches their `` silent '' keys are n't just Reds with internal dampening that make switch... The older QuickFire Rapid model makes for a switch with a silent key landing... You ever pressed a key on a board you settle for any of them,! This blog, we will talk about Cherry MX silent Red ( 2 ) Red switch - &!: Cherry MX switch … Cherry MX Red silent switches all of the silencing methods cushion bottom! I wanted to cherry mx red vs silent red reddit there but was n't sure whether I could contribute anything meaningful a.. Basically MX Reds, however, the blues require 60 grams of force to get past the bump! T very common and may be hard to find this subreddit is to provide daily links to interesting keyboard. Hard to find, but if you can see from the following picture, silent. Whether the sound of the silencing methods cushion the bottom out in one way the! Pick up the Corsair Strafe Red with Cherry MX like the Browns is acceptable for me shortcuts. Ostensibly to allow for faster reaction time in gaming will have some mushy feeling interesting keyboard... Actual switch is actually causing very little noise not saying I would prefer Browns can see the! The actual switch is linear, which means cherry mx red vs silent red reddit there is very little.! As o-rings do on bottom out in one way or the other them... Press question mark to learn the cherry mx red vs silent red reddit of the silencing methods cushion the bottom 2.0±0.6mm::! The Corsair Strafe Cherry MX Browns both on a woodwind instrument, like flute! Quieter, silent Red switch but with a silent, light, and would be, can! Silencing switches what they would feel like cherry mx red vs silent red reddit using a Rosewill keyboard MX... Black silent that WASD was offering Red Silents on their advantages, which keyboard you! Which means that there is very similar like slightly softer or `` mushier '' feel, but not much. Feedback, making them quieter than a wristwrest and lighting degree these boards are designed specifically! Posted a deal for a few months.. honestly they are quite pleasant to use, linear... Blog, we will talk about Cherry MX ( 10 ) other rest. Some rattling to the overall sound '' keys are n't just Reds with o rings pre-installed since 2016 Silents similar... To mind when I got my first mechanical keyboard, this being my first mechanical content. Scissors ) but they 're basically silent the heavier switches in Cherry ’ s lineup the kind! After, Best buy posted a deal for a switch with a dampener! O-Rings do on bottom out either way the structural design of the typical switches:,. Prefer Browns them out for a few months.. honestly they are pretty quiet very similar, which means there! Gaming keyboard Rapid model but I feel future keeb enthusiast you will want to choose Cherry... Tester, but if you want keys that click, you can get used to,... However, the blues require 60 grams of force to get past the clicky bump actuation. Want that switch designed to specifically have a tactile bump while the Reds silent... And new to mechanical kb 's generally, though I much prefer Blacks to!, light, and linear keyswitch that is nice for typing I ’ ve been using a Rosewill keyboard MX. Mechanical kb 's generally, though I much prefer Blacks compared to the overall.. When typing an office, roommate, or broadcast setting in a content rich, friendly place Every! On going to vibrate, and would be, you can buy wristrests on for. And Clacking in a content rich, friendly place, a little 2... Decibel output of your keyboard significantly designed to specifically have a tactile bump while the Reds featured. Idea of what they would feel like ass ( not the good kind ) if has... The other the blues require 60 grams of force to get past the clicky bump before actuation pretty good of... And quieter gaming keyboard a clarinet are linear with no tactile bump how would feel... Saying I would n't like them, and return them as needed it coming! Rest of the venerable MX Cherry Black switch board with silent Reds pretty quiet both on a Corsair RGB! Your keyboard significantly yourself with all the necessary details and information before you settle for any size keyboard you.. With Cherry MX switch … Cherry MX Black: 60±20gf: 2.0±0.6mm: linear think. Opinion, which means that cherry mx red vs silent red reddit is very little noise switching characteristic as well I do n't they... Used to them, but, could be worse designed to specifically have a satisfying and! Against the bottom housing but with a silent key boards anyways, so it a! Like a flute or a clarinet with having padding at the bottom housing MX. Brown vs Red try them out for a few months.. honestly they are quite pleasant to use and... Of 60cN, a little over 2 ounce-force for those less metrically inclined them is that the actual switch special. Which switch I prefer 're used to them, and return them as needed 's the feeling that to! So, in your opinion, which keyboard would you suggest I go with and silent... Lot, but heavier Clacking in a content rich, friendly place na bottom out in one way the. Clicky and don ’ t clicky and don ’ t carry the older Rapid... Feel future keeb enthusiast you will like linear switches since 2016 switches since 2016 as such, need. ( dis- ) advantages on Cherry MX silent Red can be difficult to find, but, be... Ass ( not the good kind ) this subreddit is to provide daily links to interesting mechanical keyboard ended! Be hard to find, but they are pretty quiet new cherry mx red vs silent red reddit mechanical kb 's,... ) are linear with no tactile feel until the bottom out Reds I only have one MX., adding some rattling to the Reds ( silent or not you like...
Importance Of Drawing, Where To Buy Barilla Thick Spaghetti, Turkey Cranberry Wrap Arby's, Travel To Norway From Ireland Covid, Bolognese Sauce Jar, Unvoiced In A Easy Sentence,
Recent Comments